Reviewing solutions in the 3D Solution viewer

The 3D Solution Viewer in the ACP Workspace provides users with a robust interface for analyzing and interacting with ACP generated conduit routing solutions. It allows for review of conduit placements, Electrical Model, and Background Geometry using visualization tools such as Placement Considerations, View Controls, Section Planes, and Bookmarks.

Refer to the Navigating the 3D Solution Viewer interface article for a complete description of all tools and navigation elements in the 3D Solution Viewer. This article focuses specifically on reviewing routing outcomes using the 3D Solution Viewer.

Open a solution in the 3D Solution Viewer

ACP generates 12 unique solutions for each study in your ACP project. All solutions are listed by study in the table within the Solutions tab. To differentiate the solutions, they are assigned a number from 1 to 12.

To open a solution in the 3D Solution Viewer from the Solutions table:

• Click the study name.

• Or click the Open button corresponding to the solution under the Actions column.

PRO TIP: Because 12 solutions are generated for each study, the table ca n easily grow up to hundreds of rows. To display only the solutions for a specific study:

1. Navigate to the Studies tab.

2. Open the study used to generate the solution you want to review.

3. Click the View 12 solutions button at the top right corner.

   • This switches you to the Solutions tab and automatically filters the table to the selected study.

Changing the study color

The study name and solution number of the opened solution in the 3D Solution Viewer are displayed in the dropdown at the top left corner. The solution color is the same as the study color. To change both the solution and study color, follow the steps below:

1. Click the color swatch beside the solution name.

2. Select a color from the dropdown color picker.

3. Click the Save button.

Changing the displayed solution

The solution displayed in the 3D Solution Viewer may be changed at any time.
Follow the steps below:

1. Click the solution name dropdown at the top left corner.

2. From the dropdown list, select the study.

3. Select the solution from the list next to the study dropdown.

Change background geometry

In the 3D Solution Viewer, you can overlay the generated solution in different versions of the Background Geometry.
Here’s how:

1. Click the View Controls button.

2. Expand the Show Background Geometry group.

3. Click the dropdown right below the group heading.

4. Select the preferred background geometry from the options.

Because Background Geometry influences supportability and defines obstructions to be routed around, overlaying geometry other than that used for the current study will not accurately represent their interaction and should be viewed only as a basis for comparison.

Control the model display

The visibility of specific groups of elements in the 3D Solution Viewer can be configured using View Controls.

Using View Controls

The View Controls allow you to control the visibility of different parts of the model. It’s grouped into four: Show Background Geometry, Visualizations, Electrical, and Bookmarks. For more information refer to the View Controls section of the Navigating the 3D Solution Viewer article.

Follow the steps below to use the View Controls for configuring what’s shown in the model.

1. Click the View Controls button.

   • The View Controls panel will appear.

2. All View Controls sections are enabled by default.

   • To disable the entire View Controls group, click the corresponding toggle switch to disable it.

3. To configure view controls individually,

   • Click the View Controls section heading to expand it.

   • Locate the view control you want to configure.

   • Click the visibility toggle to enable or disable it.

     • The model in the 3D Solution Viewer will update as you enable or disable the view control.

Modify the View with Section Planes

Placing Section Planes

Section Planes cut through the model to display its cross-sectional area, allowing you to get a more detailed view of how the conduits were routed in certain regions of the model.
The steps below outline how you can add a section plane, and adjust its position.

1. Position the 3D model so the plane you want to section through is visible.

   • You can use the View Cube or the navigation controls.

2. Click the Section Planes button.

   • The Section Planes pop-up will appear.

3. In the Section Planes pop-up, click the add button.

4. When the banner appears at the top, click on a surface of the model where you want to place the section plane.

5. After placing the section plane, you can use the section plane controls to do the following:  

   • Adjust the depth of the plane using the straight arrows. Click drop-down to view animation.

     1. Hover your mouse cursor over the straight arrow corresponding to the plane you want to adjust.

     2. When the arrow is selected, click and drag to the preferred depth.

   • Rotate the plane to change its orientation using the double-headed arcs. Click drop-down to view animation.

     1. Hover your mouse cursor over the double-headed arc corresponding to the plane you want to rotate in.

     2. When the double-headed arc becomes a circle, click and drag to rotate the plane to the preferred orientation.

6. Repeat the previous steps to section more planes in the model.

Deleting Section Planes

When Section Planes are no longer needed in the viewer they can be easily deleted.

1. Click the Section Planes button.

   • The Section Planes pop-up will appear.

2. Click on the Trash button next to the section plane you want to delete.

Section Planes persist across solutions within the same session, allowing you to compare their cross-sections. As you switch between solutions, the viewer maintains the current visibility and section plane settings.

However, these settings are not saved with the project. If you close your ACP Workspace or exit the project, all visibility settings (including Section Planes) will be deleted.

Explore Placement Considerations

Unrouted conduit runs in the solution can easily be viewed in the 3D Solution Viewer using the Placement Considerations button.

PRO TIP:
Type the name of a Source or Destination in the search bar within the Unrouted Runs tab to search for all related unrouted runs.

If there are no results, all runs for that element have successfully been routed.

Reviewing unrouted runs

1. Click the Placement Considerations button.

   • By default, the Placement Considerations panel will open to the Unrouted Runs tab listing all conduit runs which couldn’t be placed in Source-Destination format.

2. Select any Source-Destination pair to display the Run ID Information Panel containing the following:

   • Details of the selected run

   • Reason why the run couldn’t be placed and how to potentially resolve it

   • The Source for the Run ID

     • Click on the source name to zoom in to it

     • Note the spherical target over the element

   • The Destination for the Run ID

     • Click on the source name to zoom in to it

     • Note the spherical target over the element

   • A straight line connecting the Source the the Destination

   • The Explored Run ID visualization

     • The translucent blue shading (such as ) displays all areas of the model ACP explored as a possible (supportable) route for this Run ID.

3. Using the tools listed above, explore the the solution  to look for clues about why the Run ID was unable to be routed.
   Here are some common reasons conduits may not route:

   • Obstructions

     • Collision geometry which fully blocks any possible route between a Source and Destination.

   • Panel Fill

     • Electrical Equipment that has no additional room for conduits on the routable faces.

   • Supportability

     • Conduit racks that cannot be fully supported within the model.

     • Click here for steps to view if the area around the Source and Destination is supportable.

       1. Click View Controls.

       2. In the View Controls panel, expand the Visualizations group.

       3. Enable the toggle switch for any Supportable Volumes category, i.e. Overhead, Wall, and Floor, to visualize its supportability.

          • Overhead - Shows the supportable volume from the floor above until the nearest obstruction below, such as ceilings.

          • Wall - Highlights the area within a specific distance from walls which is supportable.

          • Floor - Highlights the supportable parts of floors based on Floor Supports in the specification.

            • This workflow is not typical, so this setting would not usually be used.

Pro Tip:

To give yourself more room in the 3D Solution Viewer, close the Placement Considerations panel, while leaving the Run ID Information panel open. Both windows will close, but the selected source-destination pair, will still be highlighted in the Viewer.

Reviewing Unknown Parts

ACP searches for available space and a supportable path for the conduit solution before placing the individual components of the Conduit Run. Sometimes, while building the run, ACP may encounter a bend it can't determine how to construct. Instead of failing the entire route, it places an element called an Unknown Part where the bend should be. These Unknown Parts are included when the conduit solution is exported to Revit, making it easy for you to locate and update the solution with the correct bend.

Follow these steps to review these Unknown Parts:

1. Click the Placement Considerations button.

   • The Placement Considerations panel will open to the Unrouted Runs by default,

2. Switch to the Parts tab where all the Unknown Parts are listed.

3. Click any part in the list to zoom in to its location and display the Run ID information panel containing the following details:

   • Part type(s) tried

   • Source(s)

   • Destination(s)

4. The section of the conduit run where ACP couldn't find a matching part will appear in orange. This issue may not occur in other solutions where the conduit run takes a different path. Use the dropdown in the top-left corner to switch solutions and check if the missing part is resolved.

When Unknown Parts are exported to your Revit project with the conduit solutions, they are placed using a Generic Model family. Currently, this family does not automatically contain a specific identifier, including Family name or Type name. They can be identified within a schedule because the Family name and Type name will be blank.

Work with Bookmarks

Bookmarks allow you to save data about and a specific view of an area within the solution. This can be useful for tracking specific parts of the solution that may require more attention or that your team wants to track in the project.

This section covers how you can create, show, navigate to, and update bookmarks.

Creating a Bookmark

1. Navigate to the location in the 3D model where you want to place a bookmark and position it in the view angle you want to capture.

2. Click the Bookmark button.

3. In the Bookmark panel, select the New Bookmark button.

4. When the banner appears at the top, click the point in the 3D model where you want to place the bookmark.

5. In the Create Bookmark pop-up, enter a Name and Description.

6. Click the Create button. The bookmark will be placed on the model.

   

Bookmarks can be shared with other team members who have access to your workspace by clicking on the Generate Link button in the top right hand corner of the bookmark information panel.

This will automatically save the shared URL to your clipboard ready to be shared.  

Controlling bookmark visibility in the 3D Solution viewer

Bookmarks appear as labels in the 3D model. Their appearance may vary between solutions because they inherit the color of the ACP study from which the solution was generated.  

Bookmarks may be hidden in one of two ways: Using the Bookmarks toggle in the View Controls panel (hides all bookmarks together), or individually within the Bookmark panel.
Follow the steps below to turn on/off the visibility of the bookmarks.

Reviewing an existing Bookmark

You can navigate to a bookmark from the Bookmark panel or via a Bookmark label:

Bookmarks are saved to a specific Solution and will not be visible in any other Solution or Study.

The Bookmarks column in the Study List shows which Studies contain Solutions with bookmarks.

Click the Bookmark button to open the Bookmarks window, where you can view details about individual bookmarks (including which Solution they belong to), and to view them in the 3D Solutions Viewer.

Updating an existing Bookmark

In the Bookmark information panel, you can update the bookmark’s Name, Description, and camera and visibility settings.

Updating the bookmark’s Name and Description

1. Click the Edit Bookmark button.

2. Update the Name and Description as preferred.

3. Click the Edit button.

   • Or select Cancel to exit the Edit Bookmark pop-up without saving your changes.

   

Updating the view in which the bookmark is shown,

1. Use the navigation controls to adjust the model to show the preferred view.

2. Click the Update current camera settings button. The bookmark will be shown in this view the next time you navigate to it.

Controlling Visibility of a Bookmark in the Bookmark Information panel

1. Use the visibility toggle at the bottom of the Bookmark Information panel to make the bookmark Visible or Hidden in the model.

Managing screenshots of a Bookmark

Provide additional context by adding screenshots of different camera angles around the bookmarked element.
Here’s how you can upload, view, and delete screenshots associated with a bookmark.  

Uploading screenshots

1. Click the Upload button.

2. In the pop-up file manager window, navigate to and select the screenshot you want to upload.

3. Click the Open button.

4. Repeat the steps to upload multiple screenshots.

   

Opening the screenshot in the image viewer

1. Hover over the screenshot.

2. Click the show button.

3. The controls of the image viewer are at the bottom. You can flip the image horizontally and vertically, rotate it clockwise or counterclockwise, and zoom in and out.

4. Use the exit button to close the image viewer.

Deleting the screenshot

1. Hover over the screenshot.

2. Click the Delete button.

Compare solutions

ACP generates 12 routing solutions for each study. Within the 3D Solution Viewer, you can compare any two solutions side-by-side. The two solutions are identified as First Solution and Second Solution.

• First Solution - The active solution in the 3D Solution Viewer. This solution defines the viewer context such as Placement Considerations, Background geometry, Electrical model, and Visualizations.

• Second Solution - Displayed as a read-only overlay, allowing you to compare its conduit routes with those in the First Solution.

You can enter the compare solution mode in two ways:

PRO TIP:

While in solution compare mode, you can change the First Solution and Second Solution at any time.

• To switch the solutions used as First Solution and Second Solution, click the swap button.

• To select a different solution, click the First Solution or Second Solution dropdown and select the study then solution from the list.

Visually comparing solutions

When visually comparing the two solutions, keep the following in mind:

• For ease of visual comparison, the two solutions are shown in different colors. The default color of the First Solution is the study’s designated color while a temporary color is assigned to the Second Solution.

  • You can change the temporary color of the Second Solution to allow for better contrast by clicking the circle beside the solution name then picking the preferred color in the dropdown color picker.

• The Placement Considerations, Visualizations and Electrical view controls, and Issues are defined by the First Solution.

• You can view and create new bookmarks for the First Solution. However, bookmarks for the Second Solution are read-only.

Comparing Solution Details

The Solution Details display information about the solution as well as the study it was generated from. In solution compare mode, you can compare these details of the First Solution and Second Solution within the 3D Solution Viewer.

Follow the steps below.

1. While in solution compare mode, click the Solution Details button.

   • This opens the Solution Details pane with the Data and Stats comparison of the First Solution and Second Solution.

     • Data tab - Shows the study data of the two solutions being compared in separate tabs.

     • Stats tab - Displays separate columns for the First Solution and the Second Solution to compare the solutions’ details.

2. In the Data tab, use the sub-tabs to show details of the First Solution or Second Solution.

   • Click any section heading, such as Electrical Model, to collapse or expand the section which details the corresponding input used to generate the solution.

   • Any warning will be shown for each one. Click View More for more details.

3. Click any section heading, such as Bends and Run IDs, to expand or collapse the corresponding section.

   • The Stats tab compares the Conduit, Bends, Run IDs, and Estimates of the two solutions.

Sharing and exiting comparison

Click the share button to share the comparison with any teammates who have access to you ACP workspace.

• ACP generates a shareable link and automatically saves it to your clipboard.

Exit solution compare mode by clicking the exit button.